Title IX Defense

Title IX Defense for College Students Accused of Sexual Misconduct

A Title IX complaint can move faster than a criminal case and can end with suspension, expulsion, or a permanent note on a transcript. It can also run alongside a police investigation. I am Lowell Sidney. I am a former Kings County prosecutor with more than 20 years of criminal defense experience, and I represent private clients in Manhattan and Brooklyn. I advise college students, and their families, who have been accused of sexual misconduct in a campus process, with an eye on any criminal exposure that comes with it.

How the Campus Process Works

Most colleges follow a similar path: a report to the Title IX office, a written notice to the accused student, an investigation with interviews and evidence gathering, a chance to review the evidence, a decision, and an appeal. The federal Title IX regulation that governs colleges now is the 2020 rule. The 2024 rule was struck down by federal courts in early 2025, and the Department of Education formally restored the 2020 text in 2026. Under the 2020 rule, a formal Title IX case at a college generally includes a live hearing where each side's advisor questions the other party and the witnesses.

Not every complaint is handled under Title IX itself. Conduct that falls outside the federal rule, such as some off-campus incidents, is often handled under the school's own code of conduct, with different procedures. The first step is to read the notice and figure out which process you are in and which rules apply.

New York's Enough Is Enough Law

Colleges in New York must also follow Article 129-B of the Education Law, known as Enough is Enough. It requires every college in the state to use an affirmative consent definition and to give accused students certain protections, including written notice of the allegations, the right to an advisor of choice at all meetings and hearings, a presumption that the student is not responsible until a finding is made, the right to review the evidence, and at least one level of appeal. It also requires a transcript notation for students suspended or expelled after a finding of responsibility for certain violent offenses, or who withdraw while charges are pending. That last rule makes withdrawing a decision to think through carefully.

The Advisor Role

You are entitled to an advisor of your choice, and that advisor can be a lawyer. Schools set rules on what an advisor may do in meetings, but at a live Title IX hearing the advisor is the one who asks the questions. I help students prepare for interviews, review the evidence file, respond in writing, prepare for and conduct questioning at the hearing where the rules allow, and draft appeals.

Interim Measures

Before any finding, a school may put measures in place such as a no-contact order, a change in class schedule or housing, or, in some cases, an interim suspension or emergency removal from campus. You generally have a right to ask for prompt review of these measures and to submit evidence. Follow every interim order exactly. A violation can lead to new charges even if the original complaint fails.

When There Is Also a Criminal Case

This is where a criminal defense lawyer matters most. The campus process is not confidential from prosecutors. What you say to a Title IX investigator, write in a statement, or text to a witness can be obtained by the police and used in court. New York law expects the campus case to continue while a criminal investigation is pending, with only short delays at law enforcement's request, so you may have to decide how to participate on campus before you know whether charges will be filed. The campus standard of proof is usually "more likely than not," far lower than in criminal court. I help students weigh whether, when, and how to give a statement so the campus case does not damage a criminal defense. If charges are filed, see my sex crimes defense page.

Appeals

If the decision goes against you, the appeal window is usually short, often a matter of days. Grounds commonly include procedural errors that affected the outcome, new evidence that was not reasonably available, and bias or conflict of interest by a decision-maker. An appeal is usually decided on the record, so the work done before and during the hearing matters most.

Frequently Asked Questions

Should I talk to the Title IX office before I have a lawyer?

It is best to get advice first. Anything you say can be used in the campus case and may be obtained by police or prosecutors. You can tell the office you will respond after speaking with an advisor.

Can my lawyer be my Title IX advisor?

Yes. Federal rules and New York's Enough is Enough law both allow an advisor of choice, and that person can be an attorney. The school sets rules on the advisor's role in meetings.

Does the campus case wait for the criminal case?

Usually not. In New York, campus proceedings generally run at the same time as a criminal investigation, with only short delays at law enforcement's request.

Will a finding go on my transcript?

At New York colleges, a suspension or expulsion after a finding of responsibility for certain violent offenses, including sexual violence, must be noted on the transcript. A notation is also required if you withdraw while charges are pending.

Can I appeal a finding?

Yes. Schools must offer an appeal, but deadlines are short and the grounds are limited, so act quickly.

 

If you or your child has received a Title IX notice or been contacted by a campus investigator, call before the first interview. I offer a free case evaluation. Call (718) 395-2067.

Contact Us Today

  • Please enter your first name.
  • Please enter your last name.
  • Please enter your phone number.
    This isn't a valid phone number.
  • Please enter your email address.
    This isn't a valid email address.
  • Please make a selection.
  • Please enter a message.
  • By submitting, you agree to receive text messages from Law Offices of Lowell J. Sidney at the number provided, including those related to your inquiry, follow-ups, and review requests, via automated technology. Consent is not a condition of purchase. Msg & data rates may apply. Msg frequency may vary. Reply STOP to cancel or HELP for assistance. Acceptable Use Policy
Locations